The Secondary Competitor Mistake Losing You Market Share

You know your main competitor. You track their pricing, features, and marketing. Meanwhile, secondary competitors—the ones you barely notice—are converting 40% of prospects who should be yours.

Secondary competitors don't compete directly but solve the same problem differently. They're the DIY solution to your SaaS product, the in-house team to your agency, the alternative approach to your methodology. Ignoring them costs you market share daily.

What Are Secondary Competitors?

Secondary competitors are businesses or solutions that satisfy the same customer need through different approaches, products, or methodologies. They compete for the same budget and solve the same problem but don't offer the same type of solution as you.

Primary vs. Secondary vs. Tertiary Competitors

Why Secondary Competitors Matter More Than You Think

The Data:

• 42% of lost deals go to secondary competitors
• 70% of companies don't track secondary competition
• Secondary competitors take 3-5 years to become primary threats
• 60% market share losses come from unexpected competition

The Blind Spot: You analyze feature matrices comparing you to direct competitors while prospects choose "none of the above" and solve the problem differently.

Types of Secondary Competition

1. DIY Solutions

The Threat: Prospects build their own solution using free tools, spreadsheets, or manual processes rather than buying yours.

Example: Social media management tool vs. Google Sheets + native platform scheduling

Why Prospects Choose It:

• No budget allocated yet
• "We can probably do this ourselves"
• Testing the need before investing
• Perceived as "free" (ignoring time cost)

How to Counter: Show total cost of ownership including time, opportunity cost, and scalability limitations. Offer free trial to prove value exceeds DIY effort.

2. In-House Solutions

The Threat: Companies hire employees or contractors instead of using your product or service.

Example: Marketing agency vs. hiring an in-house marketing team

Why Prospects Choose It:

• Want direct control over resources
• Believe in-house has better context
• Long-term cost perception
• Company size supports dedicated staff

How to Counter: Position as complement, not replacement. "Our solution + your in-house team = better results." Emphasize expertise, speed to value, and flexibility.

3. Alternative Methodologies

The Threat: Different approach to solving the same fundamental problem using different frameworks or philosophies.

Example: Project management software vs. Agile coaching and sticky notes

Why Prospects Choose It:

• Philosophical alignment with approach
• Existing investment in methodology
• Change management easier
• Cultural fit concerns

How to Counter: Show methodology compatibility. "We enhance [their approach], not replace it." Provide implementation guides for their preferred framework.

4. Status Quo (Do Nothing)

The Threat: The most common "competitor"—prospects decide not to solve the problem at all right now.

Why Prospects Choose It:

• Problem not urgent enough
• Other priorities more important
• Change resistance
• Risk aversion

How to Counter: Quantify cost of inaction. Show opportunity cost, competitive disadvantage, and future compounding problems. Create urgency through time-sensitive offers or showing peer pressure (competitors are adopting).

5. Adjacent Category Solutions

The Threat: Products from related categories that can be stretched to solve your use case.

Example: CRM systems adding social media features vs. dedicated social media management platforms

Why Prospects Choose It:

• Already using and paying for it
• Consolidation preference
• Integration benefits
• Switching cost avoidance

How to Counter: Emphasize specialization advantages, depth of features, and outcomes. "Yes, CRMs can do basic social, but here's what you miss..."

Understand your competitive position to determine resource allocation across primary and secondary competition.

Identifying Your Secondary Competitors

Customer Interview Questions

Ask Lost Deals:

• "What solution did you choose instead?"
• "If not us, how are you solving [problem] now?"
• "What almost made you choose a different approach?"
• "What other options did you seriously consider?"

Ask Current Customers:

• "What were you doing before us?"
• "What made you stop doing it yourself?"
• "What other solutions did you evaluate?"
• "What would you do if we didn't exist?"

Sales Call Analysis

Listen For:

• "We're considering building this internally"
• "We might just hire someone to handle this"
• "Can't we just use [different category tool]?"
• "We've been managing with spreadsheets"
• "We're not sure we need a solution yet"

Document Patterns: Track these responses in CRM. After 20+ conversations, patterns reveal your real secondary competition.

Market Research Methods

Search Intent Analysis: Look at what else prospects search for when researching your solution. Google Search Console and SEO tools reveal alternative approaches they're considering.

Social Listening: Monitor what prospects discuss as alternatives in Reddit, LinkedIn groups, Slack communities, and Twitter. "Should I buy [your category] or just hire someone?"

Review Site Analysis: Read competitor reviews. What do customers say they considered instead? "Almost went with doing this in-house but chose [product] instead."

Competitive Positioning Against Secondary Competition

Build-vs-Buy Positioning

For prospects considering DIY or in-house:

Content to Create:

• TCO calculators comparing your solution to DIY
• "Build vs. Buy" comparison guides
• Case studies of companies who tried DIY first
• ROI timelines showing payback period

Status Quo Disruption

For prospects "thinking about it":

Create urgency by quantifying the cost of waiting:

• "Every month you wait costs you [X revenue/savings]"
• "Your competitors adopted this [timeframe] ago"
• "The problem compounds—here's the math"
• "Limited-time implementation support for fast movers"

Content to Create:

• Cost of inaction calculators
• Industry benchmark reports showing adoption rates
• Competitive pressure case studies
• Risk analyses of delayed implementation

Feature Depth Messaging

For prospects considering adjacent category solutions:

Emphasize specialization advantages:

• "Yes, [alternative] can do basic [function], but here's what specialized tools enable..."
• Feature comparison showing depth, not just presence
• Workflow examples demonstrating efficiency gains
• Integration ecosystem specific to your category

Content to Create:

• Detailed feature comparison matrices
• "Why specialized tools outperform all-in-one platforms"
• Workflow walkthrough videos
• Power user testimonials

Use discovery meeting templates that specifically uncover secondary competition early.

Content Strategy for Secondary Competition

SEO-Focused Comparison Content

Target Keywords:

• "[Your solution] vs DIY"
• "Should I hire [role] or use [your product]?"
• "Build vs buy [your category]"
• "[Adjacent tool] for [your use case]"
• "Alternatives to [secondary competitor approach]"

Content Formats:

• Comparison blog posts
• Decision framework guides
• Cost comparison calculators
• Pros/cons analysis articles

Objection-Handling Content

Common Objections to Address:

• "We don't have budget" → ROI content showing cost of not solving
• "We can do this ourselves" → TCO content showing hidden costs
• "We're not ready yet" → Urgency content showing waiting costs
• "We'll use [other tool]" → Feature depth content showing gaps

Content Types:

• FAQ pages addressing each objection
• Video testimonials from customers who overcame objections
• Comparison pages for each secondary competitor type
• Case studies showing migration from secondary to your solution

Social Proof Against Alternatives

Testimonials to Collect:

• "We tried doing this ourselves for 6 months—wish we'd started with [product] sooner"
• "Hiring someone seemed cheaper, but [product] was actually more cost-effective"
• "We stretched [other tool] to handle this, but it was painful—[product] is purpose-built"

Display Strategy: Homepage, pricing page, and comparison pages should feature testimonials specifically addressing secondary competition.

Tracking Secondary Competitor Threats

Early Warning Signs

Market Signals:

• Adjacent category players adding features in your space
• DIY tutorial content increasing for your use case
• Your target companies posting job listings for in-house roles
• Price compression from primary competitors (suggests saturation)

Sales Signals:

• "Let me think about it" increasing as loss reason
• Longer sales cycles despite strong interest
• Budget objections from qualified prospects
• "We decided to handle this internally" responses

Monitoring Strategy

Quarterly Secondary Competitor Review:

1. Analyze last 90 days of lost deal reasons
2. Identify patterns in what prospects chose instead
3. Assess threat level of each secondary competitor type
4. Prioritize which to address with content/positioning
5. Update messaging and sales enablement

Competitive Intelligence Sources:

• Win/loss interview program
• Sales call recordings (with permission)
• Customer onboarding surveys ("What were you doing before?")
• Social listening and community monitoring
• Industry reports and analyst research

Measure competitive performance using marketing performance metrics.

Secondary Competition Type Comparison

Test Your Competitive Strategy Knowledge

Question 1: You lose a deal and the prospect says "We decided to build this functionality in-house." What should you learn from this?

Correct Answer: Your value proposition didn't adequately address speed-to-value and total cost of ownership

When prospects choose in-house development, they believe they can build what you offer faster or cheaper than buying it. This signals you didn't effectively communicate: time-to-value advantage (you're live in days vs. their 6 months development), total cost including engineers' salaries, opportunity cost of their team not working on core product, ongoing maintenance burden, or expertise gap risks. Update your positioning to address build-vs-buy decisions earlier in conversations. Create TCO calculators, case studies of companies who tried DIY first, and content about hidden costs of in-house development. Learn more about positioning strategies for competitive differentiation.

Question 2: 40% of your lost deals are "decided not to move forward right now." What does this tell you about your competition?

Correct Answer: Status quo (doing nothing) is your biggest competitor—you haven't created enough urgency

When "no decision" wins 40% of deals, you're losing to inertia, not competitors. This means your marketing and sales don't adequately answer "Why now?" You're explaining "Why us?" but not creating urgency. Solutions: quantify cost of waiting (revenue lost per month, competitive disadvantage, compound effects), showcase competitive pressure (their competitors are adopting), create time-sensitive offers, demonstrate quick wins in first 30 days, and use case studies showing what happened to companies who delayed. Shift messaging from features to "here's what inaction costs you." Explore discovery meeting techniques that uncover urgency drivers.

Question 3: A prospect says "Our existing CRM has social media features we can use." How should you respond?

Correct Answer: "That's great for basic needs. Let me ask—what specific social media results are you trying to achieve that you're not seeing today?"

This validates their current tool while shifting conversation to outcomes, not features. Adjacent category competitors (CRMs with social features) typically offer breadth not depth. Your positioning should emphasize: "Yes, CRMs can do basic social scheduling. Here's what purpose-built social media platforms enable that CRMs can't..." Then demonstrate specific advanced capabilities tied to their goals: advanced analytics, multi-account management, collaboration workflows, platform-specific optimization. Don't attack their current tool—acknowledge it handles basics, then show the gap between basics and results they actually need. Check our social media management tools to see depth vs. breadth differences.

Question 4: You notice a secondary competitor (DIY solutions) mentioned in 30% of discovery calls this quarter (up from 10% last quarter). What should you do?

Correct Answer: Create content and sales enablement specifically addressing the build-vs-buy decision

A 3x increase in DIY mentions signals a trend requiring strategic response. Actions to take: Create "Build vs. Buy" comparison content (blog posts, calculators, one-pagers), develop sales battlecards with DIY objection handling, build case studies featuring customers who tried DIY first then switched to you, launch a webinar on "True Cost of DIY Solutions," update your website FAQ to address build-vs-buy, and train sales team on TCO conversations. This is a market shift—respond with dedicated resources. If DIY mentions continue increasing, consider pricing/packaging adjustments to compete with "free" perception. Track trends with marketing analytics dashboards.

Apply competitive analysis frameworks to prioritize which secondary competitors deserve strategic attention.

Turning Secondary Competitors Into Partners

When Complementary, Not Competitive

Identify Collaboration Opportunities: Sometimes secondary competitors are actually complementary solutions. DIY tools might refer to you when prospects outgrow them. Hiring platforms might partner on "build your team + use these tools" offerings.

Partnership Examples:

• Freelancer platforms + your SaaS tool (they need tools to work)
• Consulting firms + your methodology (they need frameworks)
• Education platforms + your certification (they need credibility)

Co-Marketing Strategies:

• Joint webinars on "When to DIY vs. when to buy"
• Content collaboration on decision frameworks
• Affiliate or referral programs
• Integration partnerships

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if I'm losing deals to secondary competitors?

Implement win/loss interview programs asking prospects what they chose instead of you. Track CRM loss reasons beyond "chose competitor" to include "built internally," "decided to wait," or "used existing tool." If 30%+ of losses are non-primary competitors, secondary competition is significant.

Should I mention secondary competitors in my marketing?

Yes, but strategically. Create comparison content (blog posts, landing pages) that prospects find when researching alternatives. Don't highlight them unprompted, but address them directly when prospects raise concerns about DIY, in-house, or alternative approaches.

Can secondary competitors become primary competitors?

Absolutely. Many primary competitors today started as secondary (e.g., Slack began as a gaming company's internal tool). Monitor secondary competitors for feature expansion, funding rounds, or market traction that signals transition to direct competition.

How do I prioritize addressing secondary vs primary competition?

Allocate resources based on loss analysis. If you lose 50% of deals to primary competitors and 30% to secondary, dedicate 60/40 competitive budget split. Track where prospects actually go, not where you assume they go, to inform investment decisions.

What if doing nothing (status quo) is my biggest competitor?

This is extremely common. Combat with urgency creation: quantify cost of inaction, showcase competitive pressure (who's adopting), demonstrate compound effects of waiting, and create time-sensitive offers. Your marketing should address "Why now?" not just "Why us?"

How often should I update my secondary competitor analysis?

Review quarterly at minimum. Markets evolve, new alternatives emerge, and secondary competitors can quickly become primary threats. Annual reviews miss critical shifts. Set quarterly calendar reminders for loss reason analysis and competitive landscape assessment.

---

Ready to outmaneuver all competition? Master discovery call techniques, track marketing performance, and use SocialRails to amplify your competitive messaging across all social platforms.