Comparisons

MagicPost vs Supergrow 2026: Which LinkedIn Tool Wins?

Matt
Matt
8 min read

TL;DR - Quick Answer

8 min read

See which tool is better for you. We compare pricing, features, and ease of use.

Both are LinkedIn-only AI tools. Supergrow has carousels and costs less. MagicPost is simpler but more limited.

Quick winner: Supergrow for most users. MagicPost only if you want extreme simplicity.

Create content, post everywhere

Create posts, images, and carousels with AI. Schedule to 9 platforms in seconds.

Start your free trial

30-Second Answer

AspectWinnerWhy
PriceSupergrow$19 vs $27/month
CarouselsSupergrowBuilt-in maker
AI qualityTieBoth good
EngagementSupergrowHas engagement tools
SimplicityMagicPostFewer features
AnalyticsSupergrowBetter insights

Pricing Comparison

MagicPost

PlanMonthlyPostsKey Feature
Starter$2730/moBasic AI
Creator$39UnlimitedFull features

Supergrow

PlanMonthlyKey Feature
Starter$19AI writing, scheduling
Pro$29-39Carousels, engagement

Winner: Supergrow. Cheaper at every tier.


Quick Quiz
Easy

You want basic LinkedIn AI for the lowest price. Which tool?

💡 Tip: Think carefully before selecting your answer!


Feature Comparison

FeatureMagicPostSupergrow
AI posts
Scheduling
Content repurposing
Calendar view
Carousel maker✅ (Pro)
Voice-to-post✅ (Pro)
Engagement tools✅ (Pro)
AnalyticsBasicBetter
LinkedIn events
Multi-platform

Where MagicPost Wins

Simplicity

MagicPost is more straightforward:

  • Fewer features to learn
  • Cleaner interface
  • Faster onboarding
  • Less overwhelming

Best for: Users who want basic AI without complexity.

Content Repurposing

Both repurpose content, but MagicPost emphasizes it:

  • YouTube videos → posts
  • Blog articles → posts
  • Any URL → posts

Where Supergrow Wins

The killer feature:

AspectMagicPostSupergrow
Carousel support
TemplatesBuilt-in
Brand customizationColors, fonts
External tools neededYes (Canva)No

Carousels drive high engagement. Supergrow lets you create them directly.

Engagement Tools (Pro)

ToolMagicPostSupergrow
Engage lists
Comment assistant
First-comment
Viral feed

Voice-to-Post

Speak your thoughts → AI creates post. MagicPost doesn't have this.

LinkedIn Safety

ApproachMagicPostSupergrow
Cookie scrapingUnknownNo
Risky automationUnknownNo
Account safetyStandardEmphasized

Supergrow explicitly avoids practices that could trigger LinkedIn bans.


Quick Quiz
Easy

You want to create LinkedIn carousels without external tools. Which platform?

💡 Tip: Think carefully before selecting your answer!


Cost Analysis

Solo Creator (12 months)

ToolPlanMonthlyAnnual
MagicPostStarter$27$324
MagicPostCreator$39$468
SupergrowStarter$19$228
SupergrowPro$29-39$348-468

Savings with Supergrow Starter: $96-240/year

Feature-to-Price Ratio

What you getMagicPost ($27)Supergrow ($19)
AI posts
Carousels❌ (Starter)
Engagement❌ (Starter)
PriceHigherLower

At base tiers, Supergrow offers the same for $8 less.


Who Should Choose MagicPost?

Choose MagicPost if you...
Want the simplest possible tool
Only need AI post generation
Don't care about carousels
Prefer fewer features
Like straightforward pricing

Who Should Choose Supergrow?

Choose Supergrow if you...
Want carousel creation
Value engagement tools
Prefer lower pricing
Want voice-to-post
Care about account safety

Quick Quiz
Easy

A LinkedIn creator needs carousels and engagement tools. Budget: $40/month. Best choice?

💡 Tip: Think carefully before selecting your answer!


Neither Is Perfect

Both tools share limitations:

LimitationImpact
LinkedIn-onlyNeed other tools for multi-platform
No video toolsCan't create video content
No lead databaseSales teams need Taplio

Better Alternative

If you need more than LinkedIn:

SocialRails ($29/month)

  • All platforms
  • Unlimited AI
  • Video templates (350+)
  • Better overall value

Bottom Line

VerdictTool
Best overallSupergrow
Best valueSupergrow ($19)
Best carouselsSupergrow
Best simplicityMagicPost
Best multi-platformNeither (use SocialRails)

Supergrow wins for most LinkedIn creators. MagicPost only makes sense if you specifically want fewer features and don't mind paying more.

Create content, post everywhere

Create posts, images, and carousels with AI. Schedule to 9 platforms in seconds.

Start your free trial

Tool Guides

More Comparisons

LinkedIn Marketing

Was this article helpful?

Let us know what you think!

#SocialMedia#ContentStrategy#DigitalMarketing

📚 Continue Learning

More articles to boost your social media expertise