Community Manager vs Social Media Manager: Understanding the Key Differences

While often confused or combined, community manager and social media manager are distinct roles with different focuses, responsibilities, and skill sets. Understanding these differences is crucial for building an effective digital team.

Quick Comparison Overview

Role Deep Dive: Community Manager

Core Responsibilities

1. Community Engagement

• Respond to comments, questions, and concerns
• Facilitate discussions and conversations
• Welcome new community members
• Moderate content and enforce guidelines

2. Relationship Building

• Develop relationships with key community members
• Identify and nurture brand advocates
• Create community programs and initiatives
• Build trust through consistent interaction

3. Feedback Management

• Gather community insights and feedback
• Report user concerns to product teams
• Track community sentiment and trends
• Advocate for community needs internally

4. Crisis Response

Learn more about professional crisis response in our guide on handling negative comments on social media.

• Handle customer complaints publicly
• De-escalate tense situations
• Coordinate with support teams
• Manage reputation during crises

5. Community Growth

• Onboard new members effectively
• Create engagement initiatives
• Organize community events (online/offline)
• Develop retention strategies

Essential Skills

• Empathy & Emotional Intelligence
• Conflict Resolution
• Active Listening
• Written Communication
• Patience & Diplomacy
• Cultural Sensitivity
• Problem-Solving
• Multitasking

Tools Commonly Used

• Discord/Slack for community platforms
• Zendesk/Intercom for support
• Community platforms (Circle, Mighty Networks)
• Social listening tools (Brandwatch, Mention)
• CRM systems

Success Metrics

• Community growth rate
• Member retention rate
• Engagement per member
• Response time average
• Sentiment scores
• Support ticket deflection
• Community-generated content
• Member lifetime value

Role Deep Dive: Social Media Manager

Core Responsibilities

1. Content Strategy

• Develop content calendars
• Create platform-specific content
• Plan campaigns and promotions
• Maintain brand voice consistency

2. Content Creation

• Write compelling copy
• Design or coordinate visuals
• Produce video content
• Create stories and reels

3. Publishing & Scheduling

• Schedule posts across platforms
• Optimize posting times
• Manage content distribution
• Coordinate cross-platform campaigns

4. Analytics & Reporting

• Track performance metrics
• Analyze audience insights
• Report ROI to stakeholders
• Adjust strategy based on data

5. Trend Monitoring

• Stay current with platform updates
• Identify trending topics
• Spot viral opportunities
• Adapt to algorithm changes

Essential Skills

• Creative Writing
• Visual Design Basics
• Data Analysis
• Strategic Thinking
• Project Management
• Trend Awareness
• Platform Expertise
• Marketing Knowledge

Tools Commonly Used

• Scheduling tools (Hootsuite, Buffer, SocialRails)
• Design tools (Canva, Adobe Creative Suite)
• Analytics platforms (Sprout Social, Google Analytics)
• Content creation tools (Unsplash, GIPHY)
• Project management (Asana, Trello)

Success Metrics

• Follower growth rate
• Reach and impressions
• Engagement rate
• Click-through rate
• Conversion rate
• Share of voice
• Content virality
• ROI/ROAS

Key Differences Explained

1. Focus Area

Community Manager: Focuses on people and relationships Social Media Manager: Focuses on content and performance

2. Communication Style

Community Manager: Personal, conversational, reactive Social Media Manager: Brand-focused, strategic, proactive

3. Working Hours

Community Manager: Often requires evening/weekend availability Social Media Manager: More traditional hours with scheduled content

4. Content Approach

Community Manager: Responds to user-generated content Social Media Manager: Creates original branded content

5. Success Definition

Community Manager: Happy, engaged community members Social Media Manager: Growing metrics and campaign success

When Roles Overlap

In smaller organizations, one person often handles both roles. Common overlapping responsibilities include:

• Responding to social media comments
• Sharing community content on social channels
• Coordinating social campaigns with community
• Gathering insights from both sources
• Managing brand reputation online

Signs You Need Both Roles

You need a Community Manager when:

• You have an active user base requiring support
• Community feedback drives product development
• User retention is a key business metric
• You're building a platform or marketplace
• Customer advocacy is crucial for growth

You need a Social Media Manager when:

• Brand awareness is a priority
• You're launching regular campaigns
• Content marketing drives sales
• You need consistent posting schedule
• Competitor presence is strong on social

Salary Comparison

Understanding your target audience is crucial for both roles. Review our complete social media demographics guide to better understand platform audiences.

Community Manager Salaries (US Average)

• Entry Level: $35,000-$45,000
• Mid-Level: $45,000-$65,000
• Senior Level: $65,000-$85,000
• Director Level: $85,000-$120,000

Social Media Manager Salaries (US Average)

• Entry Level: $40,000-$50,000
• Mid-Level: $50,000-$75,000
• Senior Level: $75,000-$95,000
• Director Level: $95,000-$140,000

Factors Affecting Salary

• Geographic location
• Industry sector
• Company size
• Years of experience
• Specialized skills
• Platform expertise
• Portfolio quality

Career Progression Paths

Community Manager Path

1. Community Coordinator
2. Community Manager
3. Senior Community Manager
4. Head of Community
5. Director of Community
6. VP of Community & Customer Success

Social Media Manager Path

1. Social Media Coordinator
2. Social Media Manager
3. Senior Social Media Manager
4. Social Media Strategist
5. Director of Social Media
6. VP of Digital Marketing

How to Choose the Right Role

For Job Seekers

Choose Community Management if you:

• Love helping people
• Enjoy building relationships
• Are patient and empathetic
• Prefer variety in daily tasks
• Want to impact product development

Choose Social Media Management if you:

• Are creative and visual
• Love analyzing data
• Enjoy content creation
• Think strategically
• Want to drive business growth

For Employers

Hire a Community Manager first if:

• You have an existing user base
• Customer support is overwhelming
• User feedback is crucial
• Building loyalty is priority
• You have community platforms

Hire a Social Media Manager first if:

• You need brand awareness
• Content creation is lacking
• Competitors dominate social
• You have marketing goals
• Campaign management is needed

Working Together: Best Practices

Communication Strategies

1. Weekly sync meetings to align efforts
2. Shared content calendar for coordination
3. Clear escalation paths for issues
4. Unified brand guidelines for consistency
5. Cross-training sessions for understanding

Collaboration Opportunities

• Community-driven content campaigns
• User-generated content initiatives
• Social proof and testimonials
• Event promotion and coverage
• Crisis management coordination

Avoiding Conflicts

• Define clear role boundaries
• Establish ownership of platforms
• Create response protocols
• Share performance metrics
• Respect different work styles

Future of Both Roles

Emerging Trends

Community Management:

• AI-powered community moderation
• Virtual reality communities
• Blockchain-based community governance
• Micro-community specialization
• Community-led growth strategies

Social Media Management:

• AI content generation
• Social commerce integration
• Short-form video dominance
• Augmented reality campaigns
• Platform consolidation tools

Skills to Develop

Both Roles Should Learn:

• Basic data analysis
• AI tool utilization
• Video production
• Crisis management
• Cultural competency
• Platform diversification

Making the Decision

Questions for Organizations

1. What's our primary goal: engagement or reach?
2. Do we have existing communities to manage?
3. What's our content creation capacity?
4. How important is customer feedback?
5. What's our budget for digital roles?

Red Flags to Avoid

• Combining both roles without adjusting expectations
• Undervaluing community management
• Focusing only on vanity metrics
• Ignoring platform-specific needs
• Not providing adequate tools/resources

Conclusion

While community managers and social media managers both work in the digital space, their roles serve different but complementary purposes. Community managers build relationships and foster engagement, while social media managers drive awareness and create content.

Understanding these differences helps organizations build stronger digital teams and helps professionals choose the right career path. The most successful brands often employ both roles, leveraging their unique strengths to create comprehensive digital strategies.

---

Looking to manage your social media and community? Try SocialRails for tools that support both community engagement and social media scheduling in one platform.