Cheaper Than Metricool: The Analytics Tool Missing Content Creation (Save $216-2,064/Year)

Cheaper Than Metricool: The Analytics Tool Missing Content Creation (Save $216-2,064/Year)

Metricool built its reputation on comprehensive analytics and competitive analysis. At $18-172/month (annual billing), it promises deep insights into your social performance across platforms. But here's the reality: Most small businesses drown in analytics data while spending hours creating the actual content to post.

If you're paying $31-172/month for Metricool, you're essentially buying an analytics dashboard when you actually need help creating content. Detailed metrics don't solve writer's block or speed up video creation.

This guide reveals exactly what you're paying for with Metricool, whether analytics depth matters more than content creation speed, and how to get professional social media management with better content tools for less money.

About This Guide

This comparison focuses on small to medium businesses (under 15 employees) currently paying $18-172/month for Metricool and using primarily scheduling, basic analytics, and struggling with content creation.

What This Guide Covers: Honest assessment of Metricool's analytics versus content creation needs, real cost breakdowns, feature-by-feature ROI analysis for small teams, and alternatives. What It Doesn't Cover: Large analytics teams requiring extensive competitive intelligence, or businesses managing 50+ brand accounts needing brand-specific dashboards.

🎯 Key Takeaways

⚡ Quick Decision Helper

🚀 Switch to SocialRails if you:

✅ Check analytics once weekly but don't dive deep ✅ Spend 4+ hours/week creating content manually ✅ Need unlimited AI content generation (not in Metricool) ✅ Want video templates for TikTok/Reels (not in Metricool) ✅ Manage under 15 brands without needing per-brand dashboards ✅ Content creation bottleneck is bigger than analytics gap ✅ Ready to save $192-2,064/year on social media tools

🏢 Stay with Metricool if you:

✅ Live in analytics and competitive intelligence daily ✅ Need advanced competitor tracking for 5+ competitors ✅ Require Looker Studio integration for custom dashboards ✅ Manage 25-50 brands with separate analytics needs ✅ Data analysis is your primary focus over content creation ✅ Free plan meets your needs (1 brand, 50 posts/month) ✅ Budget allows $216-2,064/year for analytics-heavy tools

🤔 Still Not Sure?

👇 Jump to these sections:

• Cost Reality Calculator ← See your actual costs
• Feature Audit ← What you're using vs. paying for
• Switching Guide ← Migration roadmap

💰 Real Cost: What Small Businesses Actually Pay

Let's break down Metricool's true costs for small teams versus affordable alternatives.

💡 Quick Reality Check: Metricool gives you analytics to track content performance but doesn't help you create that content faster. You're data-rich but time-poor.

📋 Quick Feature Comparison

Metricool Pricing Reality 2025

Free Plan: $0/month

• 1 brand (group of accounts)
• 50 posts per month
• Basic analytics (3 months)
• 5 competitor tracking
• AI Social Media Assistant
• Reality: Good starter, but limited to 1 brand and 50 posts

Starter Plan: $18/month (annual) or $22/month (monthly)

• Up to 5 brands
• Unlimited scheduling
• LinkedIn connection
• Unlimited historical data
• All Free features
• Reality: $216-264/year for basic analytics

Starter Plus (10 brands): $31/month (annual) or $38/month (monthly)

• Up to 10 brands
• All Starter features
• Reality: $372-456/year,forced upgrade for brand limits

Advanced Plan: $45/month (annual) or $54/month (monthly)

• Up to 15 brands
• Unlimited team and client access
• Role management
• Looker Studio integration
• Zapier and Make integration
• Reality: $540-648/year for agency features

Advanced Plus (25-50 brands): $72-139/month (annual) or $88-172/month (monthly)

• 25 brands: $72/month annual, $88/month monthly
• 50 brands: $139/month annual, $172/month monthly
• All Advanced features
• Reality: $864-2,064/year,designed for large teams

X (Twitter) Add-on: +$5/month

• Additional cost for Twitter features
• Reality: Hidden cost for platform support

Hidden Costs:

• Brand limits force expensive upgrades
• Monthly billing adds 22-27% to cost
• Twitter features cost extra ($60/year)
• No unlimited AI content generation
• No video creation templates
• Analytics expertise needed to use insights

SocialRails Pricing Reality

Creator Plan: $19/month

• 27 social accounts (via connections)
• Unlimited scheduling
• 5 auto-recurring posts
• 20 AI videos/month
• 350+ video templates
• Unlimited AI content generation
• Basic analytics
• 3 workspaces

Business Plan: $39/month

• 27 social accounts
• Unlimited scheduling
• 50 auto-recurring posts
• 70 AI videos/month
• 10 workspaces
• 5 team members included
• Unlimited AI ideas

Agency Plan: $79/month

• 27 social accounts
• Unlimited scheduling
• 250 AI videos/month
• 25 workspaces
• 15 team members included
• Full features

No Hidden Costs:

• No brand/account limits
• Flat-rate monthly pricing
• All platforms included
• 15-minute learning curve
• All AI features included
• No contracts required

💰 Annual Cost Comparison

⚠️ Reality Check: Metricool's free plan is unbeatable for 1 brand. Starter is $132/year cheaper for 5 brands. BUT,you get extensive analytics without content creation tools. Evaluate: do you need deeper analytics or help creating content?

💰 Time Value Analysis

For 5 Brands (Metricool Starter $216/year vs SocialRails $228/year):

• Metricool costs $132 less annually
• But: No unlimited AI means 3+ hours/week writing content manually
• But: No video templates means 2+ hours per video creation
• SocialRails savings: 150+ hours/year with unlimited AI = $3,750 value at $25/hour
• Real ROI: Pay $132 more, save $3,750 in time = $3,618 net gain

🎯 Your Switching Decision Matrix

Side-by-Side Cost Comparison

Annual Savings Calculator

Free Plan (1 brand, 50 posts/month):

• Metricool Free: $0/year
• SocialRails Creator: $228/year
• Result: Metricool $228/year cheaper (use Metricool Free if budget is $0)

Starter (5 brands):

• Metricool Starter: $18/month Ã, 12 = $216/year
• SocialRails Creator: $19/month Ã, 12 = $228/year
• Result: Metricool $132/year cheaper (but no AI content or video tools)

Starter Plus (10 brands):

• Metricool: $31/month Ã, 12 = $372/year
• SocialRails Creator: $19/month Ã, 12 = $228/year
• You Save: $24/year (6% savings)

Advanced (15 brands):

• Metricool Advanced: $45/month Ã, 12 = $540/year
• SocialRails Creator: $19/month Ã, 12 = $228/year
• You Save: $192/year (36% savings)

Advanced Plus (25 brands):

• Metricool: $72/month Ã, 12 = $864/year
• SocialRails Business: $39/month Ã, 12 = $468/year
• Result: Metricool $84/year cheaper (analytics depth vs. content tools)

🔍 Feature Reality: What You Pay For vs. Actually Use

Metricool is designed around analytics depth and competitive tracking. Here's what small businesses actually use:

🔍 Feature Usage Audit for Small Business

💡 Reality Check: Metricool delivers extensive analytics data small businesses check once weekly but don't act on. Meanwhile, they spend hours creating content without AI or video tools.

Features You're Probably Using (40%)

✅ Social media scheduling - Essential, both have it ✅ Content calendar - Daily use, both have it ✅ Basic analytics - Weekly check, both have it ✅ Multi-platform posting - Core need, both have it ✅ Post performance tracking - Both support it ✅ Best time to post - Both show it

Features You're Paying For But Rarely Use (60%)

❌ Advanced competitor analysis (5+ competitors tracked monthly) ❌ Looker Studio integration (custom dashboard creation) ❌ Unlimited historical data (rarely reference beyond 6 months) ❌ Role management (for large teams) ❌ Zapier/Make integrations (complex automation setups) ❌ Deep analytics insights (checked but not acted on)

Features You NEED But Don't Get with Metricool

What Metricool Lacks:

• ❌ Unlimited AI content generation (only basic assistant)
• ❌ Video creation templates (350+ for Reels/TikTok)
• ❌ Simple 15-minute learning curve
• ❌ Content creation focus (analytics-heavy instead)
• ❌ No brand/account arbitrary limits

What SocialRails Includes:

• ✅ Unlimited AI content generation (write from scratch)
• ✅ 350+ video templates for TikTok/Reels/Shorts
• ✅ 15-minute learning curve vs. 1 week
• ✅ Content creation focus (balanced with analytics)
• ✅ 27 accounts (no brand limit complexity)

💡 The Small Business Reality Check

Question 1: Analytics Depth vs. Content Creation Speed

Metricool Analytics Approach:

• Comprehensive metrics across platforms
• Competitor tracking and benchmarking
• Historical data (unlimited on paid plans)
• Custom dashboards with Looker Studio
• Deep performance insights

Small Business Reality:

• Check analytics once weekly
• Look at engagement, reach, top posts
• Don't act on deep competitive insights
• Spend 10+ hours weekly CREATING content
• Bottleneck is content, not analytics

Honest Assessment: Metricool delivers analytics depth that looks impressive but most small businesses glance at weekly without deep dives. Meanwhile, creating content takes 10+ hours weekly. You don't need more data,you need faster content creation. Unlimited AI solves the actual bottleneck.

---

Question 2: Competitor Tracking ROI

Metricool Competitor Features:

• Track up to 5 competitors (Free plan)
• Unlimited on paid plans
• Benchmark performance
• Analyze competitor strategies
• Historical comparison

Small Business Reality:

• Set up competitor tracking once
• Check it occasionally
• Rarely adjust strategy based on data
• Don't have time to implement insights
• Creating own content is priority

Honest Assessment: Competitor tracking sounds strategic. Reality: most small businesses set it up, check it once a month, think "interesting," then continue with their own content plan. If you're not dedicating 2+ hours weekly to competitor analysis and strategy adjustments, you're paying for data you collect but don't use.

---

Question 3: Brand Limits and Forced Upgrades

Metricool Brand System:

• Free plan: 1 brand
• Starter: 5 brands ($18/month)
• Starter Plus: 10 brands ($31/month)
• Advanced: 15 brands ($45/month)
• Advanced Plus: 25-50 brands ($72-139/month)

Small Business Reality:

• Manage 5-15 social accounts total
• Forced to upgrade for brand limits
• Don't need per-brand analytics separation
• Artificial limits drive costs up

Honest Assessment: Metricool's "brand" system forces upgrades based on account groups, not actual analytics needs. If you manage 8 social accounts (Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn for 2 businesses), you need 2 brands minimum. But you might not need Advanced analytics,you're paying for tier limits, not features you need.

---

Question 4: AI Assistant vs. Unlimited Generation

Metricool AI Features:

• AI Social Media Assistant
• Help with captions
• Content suggestions
• Basic improvements
• Not unlimited generation

Small Business Reality:

• Need AI to write from scratch
• Blank page syndrome is the problem
• Want unlimited content ideas
• Assistant helps after you have something
• Need full generation, not just assistance

Honest Assessment: Metricool's AI assistant helps improve content but doesn't generate unlimited posts from nothing. If you're staring at a blank screen, "AI assistant" doesn't solve it,you need generation. SocialRails' unlimited AI writes complete captions from scratch, eliminating the content creation bottleneck.

🚀 What You Actually Need as a Small Business

Core Small Business Needs:

1. Easy Scheduling - Post to multiple platforms efficiently
2. Unlimited AI Content - Generate captions from scratch
3. Video Tools - Quick TikTok/Reels creation
4. Essential Analytics - See what's working (not deep dives)
5. Simple Interface - Quick learning curve
6. No Artificial Limits - Manage accounts without brand tier complexity
7. Affordable Pricing - Under $100/month

What Metricool Delivers:

✅ Easy Scheduling - YES (good calendar) ⚠️ Unlimited AI Content - NO (assistant only) ❌ Video Tools - NO (none) ✅ Essential Analytics - YES (+ deep analytics) ✅ Simple Interface - YES (1-week learning) ❌ No Artificial Limits - NO (brand tiers) ⚠️ Affordable Pricing - DEPENDS ($0-2,064/year)

Small Business Score: 3.5/7

What SocialRails Delivers:

✅ Easy Scheduling - YES (intuitive interface) ✅ Unlimited AI Content - YES (unlimited generation) ✅ Video Tools - YES (350+ templates) ✅ Essential Analytics - YES (practical metrics) ✅ Simple Interface - YES (15-minute learning) ✅ No Artificial Limits - YES (27 accounts flat) ✅ Affordable Pricing - YES ($348-2,148/year)

Small Business Score: 7/7

📊 Direct Feature Comparison for Small Businesses

💡 Real Small Business Scenarios

Scenario 1: Solo Creator (1 brand, 5 accounts)

Current Situation: Using Metricool Free, managing 1 brand with 5 social accounts, checks analytics weekly, spends 8+ hours creating content, hits 50 post/month limit often.

Why Consider Upgrade: Free plan is perfect for tight budgets. But if content creation takes 8+ hours weekly and you hit post limits, SocialRails Creator ($19/month) adds unlimited AI and video templates that save 4-5 hours weekly. Time savings value exceeds $228/year cost.

Recommendation: Keep Metricool Free if budget is $0. Upgrade to SocialRails if content creation is bottleneck.

---

Scenario 2: Small Business (5 brands, 10 accounts)

Current Situation: Paying $18/month for Metricool Starter, managing 5 brands (2 businesses Ã, 5 platforms each), checks analytics weekly but spends hours writing content manually.

Why Switch: Metricool costs $132/year less but offers no content creation help. If you spend 4+ hours weekly writing captions, SocialRails' unlimited AI saves 200+ hours/year (worth $5,000). Pay $132 more, save $5,000 in time.

SocialRails Plan: Creator ($19/month) = $228/year Time Value: 200 hours saved Ã, $25/hour = $5,000 value

---

Scenario 3: Growing Business (15 brands, 30 accounts)

Current Situation: Paying $45/month for Metricool Advanced, managing 15 brands across 3 businesses, extensive analytics sit unused, team spends 15+ hours weekly creating content, no video tools.

Why Switch: Save $192/year while gaining unlimited AI and video templates. Deep analytics look impressive but team checks basic metrics only. Content creation is the bottleneck, not data analysis. SocialRails solves the actual problem.

SocialRails Plan: Creator ($19/month) = $228/year Annual Savings: $192 (36% reduction)

---

Scenario 4: Agency (25 brands, 50+ accounts)

Current Situation: Paying $72/month for Metricool Advanced Plus (25 brands), managing multiple client accounts, analytics are valuable for reporting, but content creation takes 20+ hours weekly across clients.

Why Consider Both: Metricool costs $84/year less ($864 vs. $948) and delivers deeper analytics for client reporting. BUT SocialRails' unlimited AI saves 10+ hours weekly creating client content (worth $13,000+/year). Evaluate: is analytics depth or content speed more valuable?

Recommendation: If analytics reporting is critical, keep Metricool. If content creation bottleneck is bigger, SocialRails ROI is massive.

🔄 Switching from Metricool for Small Businesses

The migration is straightforward. Most small businesses complete the switch in 2-3 hours total.

Week 1: Evaluation & Setup (1-2 hours)

Day 1-2: Audit Current Usage

1. Check how often you analyze deep analytics
2. Count competitor tracking usage (weekly? monthly?)
3. Export scheduled posts
4. Download important analytics reports
5. List connected social accounts

Day 3-4: Setup SocialRails Trial

1. Sign up for 3-day free trial (no credit card)
2. Connect your social accounts (15 minutes)
3. Test unlimited AI content generation
4. Create test videos with 350+ templates
5. Schedule test posts across platforms

Day 5-7: Parallel Testing

1. Schedule same content in both tools
2. Compare analytics needs (essential vs. deep)
3. Test AI content generation speed
4. Create videos with templates vs. manually
5. Check posting reliability

Week 2: Migration & Cutover (1-2 hours)

Day 1-3: Full Migration

1. Recreate content calendar in SocialRails
2. Set up auto-recurring posts
3. Organize workspaces
4. Train team (15 minutes per person)

Day 4-7: Cancel Metricool (or keep Free plan)

1. Verify all posts scheduling correctly
2. Export final analytics reports
3. Cancel paid subscription OR downgrade to Free
4. Keep Metricool Free as analytics supplement if desired

Migration Questions

Q: Will I miss Metricool's deep analytics? A: Ask yourself: when did you last act on deep analytics insights? Most small businesses check basic metrics (engagement, reach, top posts) weekly and that's it. SocialRails provides essential analytics that answer 90% of questions. If you genuinely use competitor tracking and Looker Studio integration weekly, keep Metricool.

Q: Can I keep Metricool Free for analytics and use SocialRails for content? A: Absolutely! Many users keep Metricool Free (1 brand, great analytics) and use SocialRails Creator ($19/month) for unlimited AI content and video templates. Best of both worlds for $19/month total.

Q: What about competitor tracking? A: Most small businesses set up competitor tracking, check it monthly, think "interesting," then do nothing with insights. If you're not adjusting strategy weekly based on competitor data, you don't need paid competitor tracking. Focus on creating great content instead.

Q: How long will my team take to learn SocialRails? A: 15 minutes average. Metricool takes ~1 week to understand analytics features. SocialRails is intuitive,if your team uses social media, they can use SocialRails immediately.

🎯 Why Small Businesses Are Switching

Real Switching Stories

Solo Business Owner: "Metricool Free was perfect when I started,great analytics, $0 cost. But creating content took 8 hours weekly. Upgraded to SocialRails Creator at $19/month for unlimited AI. The time savings are insane,3 hours weekly. I still check Metricool Free for analytics occasionally, but SocialRails' AI solves my actual bottleneck: content creation."

Small Marketing Team (5 brands): "We paid $18/month for Metricool Starter and loved the analytics. But we spent 12 hours weekly writing content manually. Switched to SocialRails at $19/month ($132/year more) and gained unlimited AI that saves us 6 hours weekly. That's $7,800/year in time savings for $132 extra cost. Total no-brainer."

Growing E-commerce (15 brands): "$45/month for Metricool Advanced gave us deep analytics we checked once weekly but never acted on. Content creation took 15+ hours. Switched to SocialRails Creator at $19/month, saved $192/year, and unlimited AI cut content time to 8 hours. Plus video templates for product showcases. Analytics are simpler but we actually don't need the depth we paid for."

Top 5 Reasons Small Businesses Switch

1. Content Bottleneck Solved: Unlimited AI saves 3-5 hours weekly
2. Video Templates: 350+ for TikTok/Reels (not in Metricool)
3. Cost Savings: $192-2,064/year for Advanced+ users
4. Balanced Approach: Essential analytics + content creation tools
5. No Brand Limits: Manage 27 accounts without tier complexity

⚠️ When Small Businesses SHOULD Use Metricool

Be honest about your needs. Stay with Metricool if you:

✅ Budget is $0 and Free plan (1 brand) meets needs ✅ Live in analytics and check deep metrics daily ✅ Actually use competitor tracking weekly for strategy ✅ Need Looker Studio integration for custom dashboards ✅ Have analytics expertise and act on insights regularly ✅ Manage 25-50 brands with separate analytics needs ✅ Content creation is not your bottleneck (have dedicated writers)

Reality Check: If you checked 4+ boxes above, Metricool's analytics investment makes sense. If you checked 0-2 boxes and spend hours creating content, SocialRails delivers better ROI.

💬 Frequently Asked Questions

Is Metricool worth $18-172/month for small businesses?

It depends on your focus. Metricool excels at analytics depth,if you analyze data daily and adjust strategy based on insights, it's valuable. But most small businesses check basic metrics weekly and spend hours creating content. Paying for analytics when content creation is your bottleneck is backwards. Free plan is great for $0 budget. Paid plans make sense for analytics-focused teams.

Should I use Metricool Free and SocialRails together?

Smart move! Keep Metricool Free (1 brand, excellent analytics, $0) and use SocialRails Creator ($19/month) for unlimited AI content and video templates. Total cost: $19/month. You get best-in-class analytics AND content creation tools. Many small businesses run this exact combo.

Why pay more for SocialRails if Metricool Starter is cheaper?

Metricool Starter is $132/year cheaper ($216 vs. $348) but offers no content creation help. Calculate time savings: if unlimited AI saves 3 hours weekly, that's 156 hours/year worth $3,900 at $25/hour. Paying $132 extra to save $3,900 in time is smart business. Metricool gives you data; SocialRails gives you content.

Do I really need deep analytics?

Honest question: when did you last act on advanced analytics insights? Most small businesses check engagement, reach, and top posts weekly. That's it. Deep competitor tracking and historical trend analysis sit unused. If you're not dedicating 2+ hours weekly to data analysis and strategy adjustments, you don't need advanced analytics,you need help creating content faster.

What about Metricool's competitor tracking?

Looks strategic, rarely used effectively. Most small businesses set up 5 competitor profiles, check them monthly, think "interesting," then continue their own content plan without adjustments. If you're not analyzing competitor strategies weekly and implementing changes, tracking data adds no value. Focus on creating great content instead of analyzing others.

Will I miss Looker Studio integration?

Only if you build custom dashboards. Most small businesses don't have time or expertise for Looker Studio. Standard analytics dashboards in both tools show what matters: what's working and what's not. Custom dashboards look impressive but require ongoing maintenance most small teams can't sustain.

Can SocialRails' essential analytics replace Metricool's depth?

For 90% of small businesses: yes. SocialRails shows engagement, reach, top performing posts, and platform performance,metrics you actually check. If you need competitor benchmarking, historical trend analysis, and custom dashboard creation, Metricool's depth is valuable. But if you check "what's working" weekly and move on, essential analytics are sufficient.

Are brand limits really a problem with Metricool?

Yes. Metricool forces upgrades based on "brand" count (grouped accounts). If you manage 2 businesses with 5 platforms each (10 accounts total), you need 2 brands minimum. But you pay tier pricing even if you don't need advanced analytics. SocialRails gives you 27 accounts flat,no artificial limits driving costs up.

Am I being short-sighted by switching from analytics-focused tools?

Opposite. You're being strategic by solving your actual bottleneck. If content creation takes 10 hours weekly and analytics review takes 20 minutes, investing in content tools delivers 30x more time savings. Data without content is useless. Content with essential analytics (not deep dives) is what small businesses actually need.

🎯 Bottom Line: Small Business Reality

Switch if:

• ✅ Check analytics weekly but don't dive deep
• ✅ Spend 4+ hours weekly creating content
• ✅ Need unlimited AI content generation
• ✅ Want video templates for TikTok/Reels
• ✅ Content bottleneck bigger than analytics gap
• ✅ Manage 10-15 brands (save $24-192/year)
• ✅ Don't need advanced competitor tracking

Stay if:

• ❌ Budget is $0 (use Free plan)
• ❌ Analyze deep metrics and competitors daily
• ❌ Actually use Looker Studio integration
• ❌ Need advanced analytics for reporting
• ❌ Content creation is not your bottleneck
• ❌ Analytics expertise drives your strategy

The Math for 15 Brands:

• Metricool Advanced: $540/year (deep analytics)
• SocialRails Creator: $228/year (+ unlimited AI + video)
• You save: $192/year (36%) + gain content tools

Time Value for 5 Brands:

• Metricool Starter: $216/year (analytics only)
• SocialRails Creator: $228/year (+ AI saves 3 hours/week)
• Extra cost: $132 BUT saves 156 hours/year = $3,900 value

Hybrid Approach:

• Metricool Free: $0/year (analytics for 1 brand)
• SocialRails Creator: $228/year (unlimited AI + video)
• Total: $228/year for best of both worlds

🚀 Start Your Switch Today

Ready to solve your content creation bottleneck instead of just tracking it?

Step 1: Start your 3-day free trial (no credit card)

Step 2: Connect your social accounts (15 minutes)

Step 3: Test unlimited AI content generation

Step 4: Create videos with 350+ templates

Step 5: Compare time spent: creating content vs. reviewing analytics

Most small businesses realize within 48 hours that unlimited AI saves more time than deep analytics provides insights. The free trial shows you exactly what you're getting,and what you're saving.

Pro Tip: Keep Metricool Free for analytics and use SocialRails for content creation. Best of both worlds for $19/month.

📚 Related Comparisons

Still researching alternatives? Check out these detailed guides:

• Cheaper Than Buffer - Simpler tool comparison
• Cheaper Than Hootsuite - Enterprise platform alternative
• Cheaper Than Loomly - Post ideas tool comparison
• Cheaper Than SocialBee - Category system comparison
• Best Social Media Schedulers - Compare all top tools

Browse all our social media tool comparisons to find your perfect solution.

---

Ready to stop drowning in analytics and start creating content faster? Start your free trial today and see if unlimited AI saves you 3-5 hours weekly.